| 1 | ![It's Beginning to Look Like Christmas by Johnny Mathis]() | It's Beginning to Look Like Christmas | Johnny Mathis | A♭ Major | 4B | 110 |
| 2 | ![Ol' Kris Kringle (with Percy Faith & His Orchestra) by Johnny Mathis, Percy Faith & His Orchestra]() | Ol' Kris Kringle (with Percy Faith & His Orchestra) | Johnny Mathis, Percy Faith & His Orchestra | C Major | 8B | 110 |
| 3 | ![The Very First Christmas Day - Single Version by Johnny Mathis]() | The Very First Christmas Day - Single Version | Johnny Mathis | F Major | 7B | 112 |
| 4 | ![Calypso Noel by Johnny Mathis]() | Calypso Noel | Johnny Mathis | G Major | 9B | 84 |
| 5 | ![My Kind of Christmas by Johnny Mathis]() | My Kind of Christmas | Johnny Mathis | D Minor | 7A | 173 |
| 6 | ![Winter Wonderland / Let It Snow! Let It Snow! Let It Snow! (with Johnny Mathis) by Bette Midler, Johnny Mathis]() | Winter Wonderland / Let It Snow! Let It Snow! Let It Snow! (with Johnny Mathis) | Bette Midler, Johnny Mathis | G Minor | 6A | 133 |
| 7 | ![Give Me Your Love for Christmas (with Percy Faith & His Orchestra) - 1961 Version by Johnny Mathis, Percy Faith & His Orchestra]() | Give Me Your Love for Christmas (with Percy Faith & His Orchestra) - 1961 Version | Johnny Mathis, Percy Faith & His Orchestra | E Major | 12B | 89 |
| 8 | ![Sleigh Ride by Johnny Mathis]() | Sleigh Ride | Johnny Mathis | D♭ Major | 3B | 207 |
| 9 | ![The Christmas Waltz by Johnny Mathis]() | The Christmas Waltz | Johnny Mathis | F Major | 7B | 121 |
| 10 | ![Christmas In the City of the Angels by Johnny Mathis]() | Christmas In the City of the Angels | Johnny Mathis | C Major | 8B | 42 |
| 11 | ![Christmas Is... - Single Version by Johnny Mathis]() | Christmas Is... - Single Version | Johnny Mathis | C Minor | 5A | 184 |
| 12 | ![Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas - From the MGM Film,]() | Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas - From the MGM Film, "Meet Me in St. Louis" | Johnny Mathis | C Major | 8B | 173 |
| 13 | ![Home for the Holidays (feat. The Jordanaires) by Johnny Mathis, The Jordanaires]() | Home for the Holidays (feat. The Jordanaires) | Johnny Mathis, The Jordanaires | C Major | 8B | 157 |
| 14 | ![Sign of the Dove by Johnny Mathis]() | Sign of the Dove | Johnny Mathis | F♯ Major | 2B | 97 |
