| 1 | ![God Rest Ye Merry, Gentlemen by The Brothers Four]() | God Rest Ye Merry, Gentlemen | The Brothers Four | B♭ Major | 6B | 94 |
| 2 | ![Mary's Little Boy Child by The Brothers Four]() | Mary's Little Boy Child | The Brothers Four | A Major | 11B | 94 |
| 5 | ![Christmas Is a-Comin' by The Brothers Four]() | Christmas Is a-Comin' | The Brothers Four | E Minor | 9A | 156 |
| 6 | ![O Holy Night by The Brothers Four]() | O Holy Night | The Brothers Four | C Major | 8B | 37 |
| 7 | ![The Little Drummer Boy by The Brothers Four]() | The Little Drummer Boy | The Brothers Four | E Major | 12B | 124 |
| 8 | !['Twas the Night Before Christmas by The Brothers Four]() | 'Twas the Night Before Christmas | The Brothers Four | A Minor | 8A | 185 |
| 9 | ![Silent Night by The Brothers Four]() | Silent Night | The Brothers Four | B♭ Major | 6B | 83 |
| 12 | ![Medley: Hark! The Herald Angels Sing / It Came Upon the Midnight Clear / Angels We Have Heard On High by The Brothers Four]() | Medley: Hark! The Herald Angels Sing / It Came Upon the Midnight Clear / Angels We Have Heard On High | The Brothers Four | F Major | 7B | 98 |
| 13 | ![Christmas Bells by The Brothers Four]() | Christmas Bells | The Brothers Four | B♭ Major | 6B | 90 |
| 14 | ![What Child Is This? (Greensleeves) - Mono Single Version by The Brothers Four]() | What Child Is This? (Greensleeves) - Mono Single Version | The Brothers Four | E♭ Minor | 2A | 96 |
| 15 | ![God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen - 1964 Version by The Brothers Four]() | God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen - 1964 Version | The Brothers Four | D Minor | 7A | 167 |
| 16 | ![Go Tell It on the Mountain - 1964 Version by The Brothers Four]() | Go Tell It on the Mountain - 1964 Version | The Brothers Four | E Major | 12B | 103 |