| 1 | ![O Come O Come Emmanuel by Sufjan Stevens]() | O Come O Come Emmanuel | Sufjan Stevens | F♯ Major | 2B | 67 |
| 1 | ![Silent Night by Sufjan Stevens]() | Silent Night | Sufjan Stevens | C Major | 8B | 93 |
| 1 | ![Angels We Have Heard on High by Sufjan Stevens]() | Angels We Have Heard on High | Sufjan Stevens | F Major | 7B | 114 |
| 1 | ![The Little Drummer Boy by Sufjan Stevens]() | The Little Drummer Boy | Sufjan Stevens | F Major | 7B | 172 |
| 1 | ![Once in Royal David's City by Sufjan Stevens]() | Once in Royal David's City | Sufjan Stevens | F Major | 7B | 206 |
| 2 | ![O Come O Come Emmanuel by Sufjan Stevens]() | O Come O Come Emmanuel | Sufjan Stevens | E♭ Minor | 2A | 127 |
| 2 | ![Come on! Let's Boogey to the Elf Dance! by Sufjan Stevens]() | Come on! Let's Boogey to the Elf Dance! | Sufjan Stevens | G Major | 9B | 120 |
| 2 | ![Away In A Manger by Sufjan Stevens]() | Away In A Manger | Sufjan Stevens | G Major | 9B | 116 |
| 2 | ![Put the Lights On the Tree by Sufjan Stevens]() | Put the Lights On the Tree | Sufjan Stevens | C Major | 8B | 118 |
| 2 | ![Get Behind Me, Santa! by Sufjan Stevens]() | Get Behind Me, Santa! | Sufjan Stevens | G Major | 9B | 129 |
| 3 | ![Jingle Bells by Sufjan Stevens]() | Jingle Bells | Sufjan Stevens | F Major | 7B | 116 |
| 3 | ![We Three Kings by Sufjan Stevens]() | We Three Kings | Sufjan Stevens | G Major | 9B | 96 |
| 3 | ![Come Thou Fount of Every Blessing by Sufjan Stevens]() | Come Thou Fount of Every Blessing | Sufjan Stevens | B Major | 1B | 123 |
| 3 | ![We're Goin' To the Country! by Sufjan Stevens]() | We're Goin' To the Country! | Sufjan Stevens | C Major | 8B | 75 |
| 3 | ![Hey Guys! It's Christmas Time! by Sufjan Stevens]() | Hey Guys! It's Christmas Time! | Sufjan Stevens | B♭ Major | 6B | 97 |
| 4 | ![I Saw Three Ships by Sufjan Stevens]() | I Saw Three Ships | Sufjan Stevens | F♯ Major | 2B | 96 |
| 4 | ![The First Noel by Sufjan Stevens]() | The First Noel | Sufjan Stevens | E Major | 12B | 93 |
| 4 | ![Lo! How A Rose E'er Blooming by Sufjan Stevens]() | Lo! How A Rose E'er Blooming | Sufjan Stevens | D Major | 10B | 91 |
| 4 | ![O Holy Night by Sufjan Stevens]() | O Holy Night | Sufjan Stevens | C Major | 8B | 111 |
| 4 | ![Christmas in July by Sufjan Stevens]() | Christmas in July | Sufjan Stevens | F Major | 7B | 128 |
| 5 | ![Did I Make You Cry On Christmas Day? (Well, You Deserved It!) by Sufjan Stevens]() | Did I Make You Cry On Christmas Day? (Well, You Deserved It!) | Sufjan Stevens | D Major | 10B | 113 |
| 5 | ![It's Christmas! Let's Be Glad! by Sufjan Stevens]() | It's Christmas! Let's Be Glad! | Sufjan Stevens | G Major | 9B | 159 |
| 5 | ![Only at Christmas Time by Sufjan Stevens]() | Only at Christmas Time | Sufjan Stevens | C Major | 8B | 115 |
| 5 | ![That Was the Worst Christmas Ever! by Sufjan Stevens]() | That Was the Worst Christmas Ever! | Sufjan Stevens | G Minor | 6A | 140 |
| 5 | ![Lo! How A Rose E'er Blooming by Sufjan Stevens]() | Lo! How A Rose E'er Blooming | Sufjan Stevens | F Major | 7B | 100 |
| 6 | ![Ding! Dong! by Sufjan Stevens]() | Ding! Dong! | Sufjan Stevens | D Minor | 7A | 151 |
| 6 | ![Jupiter Winter by Sufjan Stevens]() | Jupiter Winter | Sufjan Stevens | D Major | 10B | 132 |
| 6 | ![Holy Holy, etc. by Sufjan Stevens]() | Holy Holy, etc. | Sufjan Stevens | G Major | 9B | 128 |
| 6 | ![The Incarnation by Sufjan Stevens]() | The Incarnation | Sufjan Stevens | C Major | 8B | 136 |
| 6 | ![Once in Royal David's City by Sufjan Stevens]() | Once in Royal David's City | Sufjan Stevens | E♭ Major | 5B | 164 |
| 7 | ![All the King's Horns by Sufjan Stevens]() | All the King's Horns | Sufjan Stevens | E Minor | 9A | 123 |
| 7 | ![Joy To The World by Sufjan Stevens]() | Joy To The World | Sufjan Stevens | D♭ Major | 3B | 137 |
| 7 | ![Amazing Grace by Sufjan Stevens]() | Amazing Grace | Sufjan Stevens | F Major | 7B | 88 |
| 7 | ![Hark! The Herald Angels Sing! by Sufjan Stevens]() | Hark! The Herald Angels Sing! | Sufjan Stevens | F Major | 7B | 114 |
| 7 | ![Sister Winter by Sufjan Stevens]() | Sister Winter | Sufjan Stevens | E♭ Major | 5B | 120 |
| 8 | ![O Come O Come Emmanuel by Sufjan Stevens]() | O Come O Come Emmanuel | Sufjan Stevens | N/A | N/A | N/A |
| 8 | ![The Friendly Beasts by Sufjan Stevens]() | The Friendly Beasts | Sufjan Stevens | D Major | 10B | 118 |
| 8 | ![What Child Is This Anyway? by Sufjan Stevens]() | What Child Is This Anyway? | Sufjan Stevens | E Minor | 9A | 105 |
| 9 | ![Bring A Torch, Jeanette, Isabella by Sufjan Stevens]() | Bring A Torch, Jeanette, Isabella | Sufjan Stevens | D♭ Major | 3B | 127 |
| 9 | ![Star of Wonder by Sufjan Stevens]() | Star of Wonder | Sufjan Stevens | F Major | 7B | 110 |
| 10 | ![Holy, Holy, Holy by Sufjan Stevens]() | Holy, Holy, Holy | Sufjan Stevens | D Major | 10B | 140 |
| 11 | ![The Winter Solstice by Sufjan Stevens]() | The Winter Solstice | Sufjan Stevens | C Major | 8B | 100 |