| 1 | ![Angels We Have Heard On High by Third Day]() | Angels We Have Heard On High | Third Day | E Major | 12B | 98 |
| 2 | ![Go Tell It On The Mountain by Tenth Avenue North]() | Go Tell It On The Mountain | Tenth Avenue North | G Major | 9B | 71 |
| 3 | ![The First Noel by Revive]() | The First Noel | Revive | D Major | 10B | 114 |
| 4 | ![Silent Night (Emmanuel) by Matt Maher]() | Silent Night (Emmanuel) | Matt Maher | A Major | 11B | 105 |
| 5 | ![The Night Before Christmas by Brandon Heath]() | The Night Before Christmas | Brandon Heath | B♭ Major | 6B | 144 |
| 6 | ![O Holy Night by Kerrie Roberts]() | O Holy Night | Kerrie Roberts | G Major | 9B | 163 |
| 7 | ![Joy to the World by Casting Crowns]() | Joy to the World | Casting Crowns | D Major | 10B | 182 |
| 8 | ![What Child Is This? by Building 429]() | What Child Is This? | Building 429 | E Minor | 9A | 145 |
| 9 | ![Do You Hear What I Hear? by Anthem Lights]() | Do You Hear What I Hear? | Anthem Lights | G Minor | 6A | 170 |
| 10 | ![All Is Well by Michael W. Smith]() | All Is Well | Michael W. Smith | A Major | 11B | 74 |
| 11 | ![It Came Upon The Midnight Clear by Jars Of Clay]() | It Came Upon The Midnight Clear | Jars Of Clay | G Major | 9B | 110 |
| 12 | ![O Little Town Of Bethlehem by Rebecca St. James]() | O Little Town Of Bethlehem | Rebecca St. James | A Minor | 8A | 178 |