| 1 | ![When a Child Is Born by Johnny Mathis]() | When a Child Is Born | Johnny Mathis | D Major | 10B | 129 |
| 1 | ![A Certain Smile by Johnny Mathis]() | A Certain Smile | Johnny Mathis | D Major | 10B | 129 |
| 2 | ![Teacher, Teacher (with Ray Ellis & His Orchestra) - Single Version by Johnny Mathis, Ray Ellis And His Orchestra]() | Teacher, Teacher (with Ray Ellis & His Orchestra) - Single Version | Johnny Mathis, Ray Ellis And His Orchestra | D Major | 10B | 129 |
| 2 | ![Too Much, Too Little, Too Late by Johnny Mathis]() | Too Much, Too Little, Too Late | Johnny Mathis | D Major | 10B | 129 |
| 3 | ![Someone by Johnny Mathis]() | Someone | Johnny Mathis | D Major | 10B | 129 |
| 3 | ![Gone Gone Gone by Johnny Mathis]() | Gone Gone Gone | Johnny Mathis | B Minor | 10A | 120 |
| 4 | ![I'm Stone in Love with You by Johnny Mathis]() | I'm Stone in Love with You | Johnny Mathis | D Major | 10B | 129 |
| 4 | ![Misty by Johnny Mathis]() | Misty | Johnny Mathis | D Major | 10B | 129 |
| 5 | ![What Will My Mary Say by Johnny Mathis]() | What Will My Mary Say | Johnny Mathis | D Major | 10B | 129 |
| 5 | ![Wild Is the Wind (with Ray Ellis & His Orchestra) by Johnny Mathis, Ray Ellis And His Orchestra]() | Wild Is the Wind (with Ray Ellis & His Orchestra) | Johnny Mathis, Ray Ellis And His Orchestra | D Major | 10B | 129 |
| 6 | ![No Love (But Your Love) by Johnny Mathis]() | No Love (But Your Love) | Johnny Mathis | D Major | 10B | 129 |
| 6 | ![Maria by Johnny Mathis]() | Maria | Johnny Mathis | D Major | 10B | 129 |
| 7 | ![Come to Me - From the Television Production]() | Come to Me - From the Television Production "Come to Me" | Johnny Mathis | D Major | 10B | 129 |
| 7 | ![How to Handle a Woman - From the B'way Musical]() | How to Handle a Woman - From the B'way Musical "Camelot" | Johnny Mathis | D Major | 10B | 129 |
| 8 | ![Sooner or Later by Johnny Mathis]() | Sooner or Later | Johnny Mathis | D Major | 10B | 129 |
| 8 | ![All the Time - From the B'way Musical]() | All the Time - From the B'way Musical "Oh, Captain!" | Johnny Mathis | D Major | 10B | 129 |
| 9 | ![Wonderful Wonderful (with Ray Conniff & His Orchestra & Chorus) by Johnny Mathis, Ray Conniff]() | Wonderful Wonderful (with Ray Conniff & His Orchestra & Chorus) | Johnny Mathis, Ray Conniff | D Major | 10B | 129 |
| 9 | ![I'll Search My Heart by Johnny Mathis]() | I'll Search My Heart | Johnny Mathis | D Major | 10B | 129 |
| 10 | ![Bye Bye Barbara by Johnny Mathis]() | Bye Bye Barbara | Johnny Mathis | D Major | 10B | 129 |
| 10 | ![It's Not for Me to Say by Johnny Mathis]() | It's Not for Me to Say | Johnny Mathis | D Major | 10B | 129 |
| 11 | ![On a Clear Day (You Can See Forever) - From the B'way Musical,]() | On a Clear Day (You Can See Forever) - From the B'way Musical, "On a Clear Day (You Can See Forever)" | Johnny Mathis | D Major | 10B | 129 |
| 11 | ![Call Me by Johnny Mathis]() | Call Me | Johnny Mathis | D Major | 10B | 129 |
| 12 | ![A Time For Us by Johnny Mathis]() | A Time For Us | Johnny Mathis | D Major | 10B | 129 |
| 12 | ![You Are Beautiful - From the B'way Musical]() | You Are Beautiful - From the B'way Musical "Flower Drum Song" | Johnny Mathis | D Major | 10B | 129 |
| 13 | ![I'm Coming Home by Johnny Mathis]() | I'm Coming Home | Johnny Mathis | D Major | 10B | 129 |
| 13 | ![Let's Love by Johnny Mathis]() | Let's Love | Johnny Mathis | D Major | 10B | 129 |
| 14 | ![Life Is A Song Worth Singing by Johnny Mathis]() | Life Is A Song Worth Singing | Johnny Mathis | D Major | 10B | 129 |
| 14 | ![Chances Are by Johnny Mathis]() | Chances Are | Johnny Mathis | D Major | 10B | 129 |
| 15 | ![Small World by Johnny Mathis]() | Small World | Johnny Mathis | D Major | 10B | 129 |
| 15 | ![Sweet Thursday by Johnny Mathis]() | Sweet Thursday | Johnny Mathis | B♭ Major | 6B | 118 |
| 16 | ![Every Step of the Way by Johnny Mathis]() | Every Step of the Way | Johnny Mathis | C Minor | 5A | 80 |
| 16 | ![The Twelfth Of Never by Johnny Mathis]() | The Twelfth Of Never | Johnny Mathis | D Major | 10B | 129 |
| 17 | ![Friends In Love by Johnny Mathis]() | Friends In Love | Johnny Mathis | D Major | 10B | 129 |
| 17 | ![The Story of Our Love by Johnny Mathis]() | The Story of Our Love | Johnny Mathis | D Major | 10B | 129 |
| 18 | ![The Best of Everything - From the 20th Century Fox Film]() | The Best of Everything - From the 20th Century Fox Film "The Best of Everything" | Johnny Mathis | A Major | 11B | 81 |
| 18 | ![Marianna by Johnny Mathis]() | Marianna | Johnny Mathis | D Major | 10B | 129 |
| 19 | ![Gina by Johnny Mathis]() | Gina | Johnny Mathis | D Major | 10B | 129 |
| 19 | ![Wasn't the Summer Short? (with Ray Ellis & His Orchestra) by Johnny Mathis, Ray Ellis And His Orchestra]() | Wasn't the Summer Short? (with Ray Ellis & His Orchestra) | Johnny Mathis, Ray Ellis And His Orchestra | A Major | 11B | 152 |
| 20 | ![You're All I Need to Get By (feat. Deniece Williams) by Johnny Mathis, Deniece Williams]() | You're All I Need to Get By (feat. Deniece Williams) | Johnny Mathis, Deniece Williams | D Major | 10B | 129 |
| 20 | ![My Love for You by Johnny Mathis]() | My Love for You | Johnny Mathis | C Major | 8B | 110 |
| 21 | ![Starbright (with Glenn Osser & His Orchestra) by Johnny Mathis, Glenn Osser & His Orchestra]() | Starbright (with Glenn Osser & His Orchestra) | Johnny Mathis, Glenn Osser & His Orchestra | D Major | 10B | 129 |
| 21 | ![Winter Wonderland (with Percy Faith & His Orchestra) by Johnny Mathis, Percy Faith & His Orchestra]() | Winter Wonderland (with Percy Faith & His Orchestra) | Johnny Mathis, Percy Faith & His Orchestra | D Major | 10B | 129 |