| 1 | ![We Got the Beat by Company of Head Over Heels - A New Musical]() | We Got the Beat | Company of Head Over Heels - A New Musical | D Major | 10B | 76 |
| 2 | ![Beautiful by Bonnie Milligan, Head Over Heels - A New Musical Ensemble]() | Beautiful | Bonnie Milligan, Head Over Heels - A New Musical Ensemble | A Major | 11B | 154 |
| 3 | ![Vision of Nowness by Peppermint, Head Over Heels - A New Musical Ensemble]() | Vision of Nowness | Peppermint, Head Over Heels - A New Musical Ensemble | F♯ Minor | 11A | 129 |
| 4 | ![Get Up and Go by Jeremy Kushnier, Company of Head Over Heels - A New Musical]() | Get Up and Go | Jeremy Kushnier, Company of Head Over Heels - A New Musical | B Minor | 10A | 102 |
| 5 | ![Mad About You by Andrew Durand, Head Over Heels - A New Musical Male Ensemble]() | Mad About You | Andrew Durand, Head Over Heels - A New Musical Male Ensemble | A Major | 11B | 142 |
| 6 | ![Good Girl by Alexandra Socha, Taylor Iman Jones, Bonnie Milligan]() | Good Girl | Alexandra Socha, Taylor Iman Jones, Bonnie Milligan | A Major | 11B | 136 |
| 7 | ![Automatic Rainy Day by Bonnie Milligan, Taylor Iman Jones]() | Automatic Rainy Day | Bonnie Milligan, Taylor Iman Jones | G Major | 9B | 134 |
| 8 | ![Vacation by Taylor Iman Jones, Head Over Heels - A New Musical Femaile Ensemble]() | Vacation | Taylor Iman Jones, Head Over Heels - A New Musical Femaile Ensemble | F Major | 7B | 154 |
| 9 | ![How Much More by Bonnie Milligan]() | How Much More | Bonnie Milligan | D♭ Minor | 12A | 100 |
| 10 | ![Our Lips Are Sealed by Alexandra Socha, Andrew Durand, Taylor Iman Jones, Bonnie Milligan, Head Over Heels - A New Musical Ensemble]() | Our Lips Are Sealed | Alexandra Socha, Andrew Durand, Taylor Iman Jones, Bonnie Milligan, Head Over Heels - A New Musical Ensemble | A♭ Major | 4B | 132 |
| 11 | ![Head Over Heels by Andrew Durand, Alexandra Socha, Taylor Iman Jones, Bonnie Milligan, Head Over Heels - A New Musical Ensemble]() | Head Over Heels | Andrew Durand, Alexandra Socha, Taylor Iman Jones, Bonnie Milligan, Head Over Heels - A New Musical Ensemble | D Major | 10B | 160 |
| 12 | ![This Old Feeling by Rachel York, Jeremy Kushnier]() | This Old Feeling | Rachel York, Jeremy Kushnier | A Major | 11B | 185 |
| 13 | ![Turn to You by Taylor Iman Jones, Bonnie Milligan, Head Over Heels - A New Musical Ensemble]() | Turn to You | Taylor Iman Jones, Bonnie Milligan, Head Over Heels - A New Musical Ensemble | D Major | 10B | 156 |
| 14 | ![Heaven Is a Place on Earth by Peppermint, Rachel York, Jeremy Kushnier, Head Over Heels - A New Musical Ensemble]() | Heaven Is a Place on Earth | Peppermint, Rachel York, Jeremy Kushnier, Head Over Heels - A New Musical Ensemble | C Minor | 5A | 123 |
| 15 | ![Here You Are by Alexandra Socha, Company of Head Over Heels - A New Musical]() | Here You Are | Alexandra Socha, Company of Head Over Heels - A New Musical | C Major | 8B | 90 |
| 16 | ![Finale by Company of Head Over Heels - A New Musical]() | Finale | Company of Head Over Heels - A New Musical | A Minor | 8A | 79 |
| 17 | ![Get Up and Go (Reprise) by Kimberly Grigsby, Ann Klein, Bess Rogers, Catherine Popper, Dena Tauriello]() | Get Up and Go (Reprise) | Kimberly Grigsby, Ann Klein, Bess Rogers, Catherine Popper, Dena Tauriello | C Major | 8B | 105 |
| 18 | ![Turn to You (Pre-prise) - Bonus Track by Tom Alan Robbins]() | Turn to You (Pre-prise) - Bonus Track | Tom Alan Robbins | F♯ Major | 2B | 42 |
| 19 | ![Automatic Rainy Day (Acoustic Version) - Bonus Track by Bonnie Milligan, Taylor Iman Jones]() | Automatic Rainy Day (Acoustic Version) - Bonus Track | Bonnie Milligan, Taylor Iman Jones | G Major | 9B | 130 |
| 20 | ![This Town - Bonus Track by The Go-Go's]() | This Town - Bonus Track | The Go-Go's | E Minor | 9A | 147 |