| 1 | ![Chances Are (with Ray Conniff & His Orchestra) by Johnny Mathis, Ray Conniff]() | Chances Are (with Ray Conniff & His Orchestra) | Johnny Mathis, Ray Conniff | B♭ Major | 6B | 84 |
| 2 | ![All the Time - From the B'way Musical]() | All the Time - From the B'way Musical "Oh, Captain!" | Johnny Mathis | F Major | 7B | 180 |
| 3 | ![The Twelfth Of Never by Johnny Mathis]() | The Twelfth Of Never | Johnny Mathis | F Major | 7B | 171 |
| 4 | ![When Sunny Gets Blue by Johnny Mathis]() | When Sunny Gets Blue | Johnny Mathis | A♭ Major | 4B | 129 |
| 5 | ![When I Am With You by Johnny Mathis]() | When I Am With You | Johnny Mathis | B♭ Major | 6B | 78 |
| 6 | ![Wonderful, Wonderful by Johnny Mathis]() | Wonderful, Wonderful | Johnny Mathis | C Minor | 5A | 145 |
| 7 | ![It's Not For Me To Say by Johnny Mathis]() | It's Not For Me To Say | Johnny Mathis | A♭ Major | 4B | 75 |
| 8 | ![Come to Me - From the Television Production]() | Come to Me - From the Television Production "Come to Me" | Johnny Mathis | G Minor | 6A | 80 |
| 9 | ![Wild Is the Wind (with Ray Ellis & His Orchestra) by Johnny Mathis, Ray Ellis & His Orchestra]() | Wild Is the Wind (with Ray Ellis & His Orchestra) | Johnny Mathis, Ray Ellis & His Orchestra | A Minor | 8A | 82 |
| 10 | ![Warm and Tender by Johnny Mathis]() | Warm and Tender | Johnny Mathis | F Minor | 4A | 88 |
| 11 | ![No Love (But Your Love) by Johnny Mathis]() | No Love (But Your Love) | Johnny Mathis | E Minor | 9A | 94 |
| 12 | ![I Look at You by Johnny Mathis]() | I Look at You | Johnny Mathis | A♭ Minor | 1A | 92 |