| 1 | ![Santa Barbara Skies by James Roday, Dulé Hill]() | Santa Barbara Skies | James Roday, Dulé Hill | D Major | 10B | 85 |
| 2 | ![Z's Lament by Anthony Rapp]() | Z's Lament | Anthony Rapp | A♭ Major | 4B | 90 |
| 3 | ![I've Heard It Both Ways by James Roday, Timothy Omundson, Maggie Lawson]() | I've Heard It Both Ways | James Roday, Timothy Omundson, Maggie Lawson | D Major | 10B | 134 |
| 4 | ![Sleigh Bells and Songs by Ally Sheedy]() | Sleigh Bells and Songs | Ally Sheedy | C Major | 8B | 99 |
| 5 | ![(When You¹re) Making Up a Song by James Roday, Maggie Lawson, Dulé Hill, Ally Sheedy]() | (When You¹re) Making Up a Song | James Roday, Maggie Lawson, Dulé Hill, Ally Sheedy | D Major | 10B | 115 |
| 6 | ![Often It¹s the Opposite by Kurt Fuller, Timothy Omundson, Maggie Lawson]() | Often It¹s the Opposite | Kurt Fuller, Timothy Omundson, Maggie Lawson | D♭ Minor | 12A | 100 |
| 7 | ![Into the Woods / I Hurt No One by Anthony Rapp, James Roday]() | Into the Woods / I Hurt No One | Anthony Rapp, James Roday | A Major | 11B | 100 |
| 8 | ![Act II Storybook Open by Adam Cohen]() | Act II Storybook Open | Adam Cohen | D♭ Major | 3B | 103 |
| 9 | ![I¹ve Heard It Both Ways (Reprise One) by Timothy Omundson]() | I¹ve Heard It Both Ways (Reprise One) | Timothy Omundson | D Major | 10B | 66 |
| 10 | ![Under Santa Barbara Skies Reprise by Maggie Lawson, Timothy Omundson, Kirsten Nelson]() | Under Santa Barbara Skies Reprise | Maggie Lawson, Timothy Omundson, Kirsten Nelson | F♯ Major | 2B | 77 |
| 11 | ![I¹ve Heard It Both Ways (Reprise Two) by James Roday, Timothy Omundson, Maggie Lawson]() | I¹ve Heard It Both Ways (Reprise Two) | James Roday, Timothy Omundson, Maggie Lawson | F Major | 7B | 135 |
| 12 | ![It¹s Her by Adam Cohen]() | It¹s Her | Adam Cohen | D Major | 10B | 101 |
| 13 | ![Promised Land by Jimmi Simpson, Ally Sheedy]() | Promised Land | Jimmi Simpson, Ally Sheedy | G Major | 9B | 137 |
| 14 | ![Shawn Hears the Theme / The Breakdown by James Roday, Anthony Rapp]() | Shawn Hears the Theme / The Breakdown | James Roday, Anthony Rapp | C Minor | 5A | 150 |
| 15 | ![Gus in the Spotlight by Dulé Hill]() | Gus in the Spotlight | Dulé Hill | A Major | 11B | 140 |
| 16 | ![The Surrender by Anthony Rapp]() | The Surrender | Anthony Rapp | B♭ Major | 6B | 72 |
| 17 | ![Jamaican Inspector by Dulé Hill]() | Jamaican Inspector | Dulé Hill | F Major | 7B | 82 |