| 1 | ![Once in Royal David's City (Arr. H.J. Gauntlett and a.H. Mann for choir, descant by P. Ledger) by Henry John Grauntlett, Amy Bartram, Trinity Church Choir, New York, Owen Burdick]() | Once in Royal David's City (Arr. H.J. Gauntlett and a.H. Mann for choir, descant by P. Ledger) | Henry John Grauntlett, Amy Bartram, Trinity Church Choir, New York, Owen Burdick | E♭ Major | 5B | 129 |
| 2 | ![Sans Day Carol (Arr. J. Rutter for choir) by Traditional, Trinity Church Choir, New York, Owen Burdick]() | Sans Day Carol (Arr. J. Rutter for choir) | Traditional, Trinity Church Choir, New York, Owen Burdick | E♭ Major | 5B | 111 |
| 3 | ![Weihnachtslieder, Op. 8: No. 3, Die Könige by Peter Cornelius, Richard Lippold, Trinity Church Choir, New York, Owen Burdick]() | Weihnachtslieder, Op. 8: No. 3, Die Könige | Peter Cornelius, Richard Lippold, Trinity Church Choir, New York, Owen Burdick | F♯ Major | 2B | 173 |
| 4 | ![I Sing of a Maiden by Patrick Hadley, Trinity Church Choir, New York, Owen Burdick]() | I Sing of a Maiden | Patrick Hadley, Trinity Church Choir, New York, Owen Burdick | E♭ Major | 5B | 129 |
| 5 | ![Adeste fideles (O Come All Ye Faithful) [Arr. P. Breiner for Choir] by John Francis Wade, Trinity Church Choir, New York]() | Adeste fideles (O Come All Ye Faithful) [Arr. P. Breiner for Choir] | John Francis Wade, Trinity Church Choir, New York | G Major | 9B | 77 |
| 6 | ![The Holy and the Ivy (Arr. H.W. Davies for choir) by Traditional, Trinity Church Choir, New York]() | The Holy and the Ivy (Arr. H.W. Davies for choir) | Traditional, Trinity Church Choir, New York | G Major | 9B | 99 |
| 7 | ![In the Bleak Midwinter by Harold Darke, Barbara Lynne Jamison, Stephen Sands, Trinity Church Choir, New York]() | In the Bleak Midwinter | Harold Darke, Barbara Lynne Jamison, Stephen Sands, Trinity Church Choir, New York | G Major | 9B | 82 |
| 8 | ![I Wonder as I Wander (Arr. J. Rutter for Voice & Choir) by Traditional, Ann Hoyt, Stephen Sands, Trinity Church Choir, New York, Owen Burdick]() | I Wonder as I Wander (Arr. J. Rutter for Voice & Choir) | Traditional, Ann Hoyt, Stephen Sands, Trinity Church Choir, New York, Owen Burdick | E Minor | 9A | 77 |
| 9 | ![Adam Lay Ybounden by Boris Ord, Trinity Church Choir, New York]() | Adam Lay Ybounden | Boris Ord, Trinity Church Choir, New York | B♭ Minor | 3A | 93 |
| 10 | ![O Little Town of Bethlehem (Arr. R. Vaughan Williams and P. Ledger for choir, descant by T. Armstrong) by Forest Green, Trinity Church Choir, New York]() | O Little Town of Bethlehem (Arr. R. Vaughan Williams and P. Ledger for choir, descant by T. Armstrong) | Forest Green, Trinity Church Choir, New York | F Major | 7B | 76 |
| 11 | ![I Saw 3 Ships (Arr. J. Rutter for Choir) by Traditional, Trinity Church Choir, New York]() | I Saw 3 Ships (Arr. J. Rutter for Choir) | Traditional, Trinity Church Choir, New York | B♭ Major | 6B | 95 |
| 12 | ![In dulci jubilo by Traditional, Trinity Church Choir, New York]() | In dulci jubilo | Traditional, Trinity Church Choir, New York | F Major | 7B | 102 |
| 13 | ![Away in a Manger (Arr. D. Willcocks for Soprano & Choir) by William J. Kirkpatrick, Ann Hoyt, Trinity Church Choir, New York]() | Away in a Manger (Arr. D. Willcocks for Soprano & Choir) | William J. Kirkpatrick, Ann Hoyt, Trinity Church Choir, New York | A Major | 11B | 80 |
| 14 | ![Of the Father's Heart Begotten (Arr. D. Willcocks) by Theodoricus Petri Nylandensis, Trinity Church Choir, New York]() | Of the Father's Heart Begotten (Arr. D. Willcocks) | Theodoricus Petri Nylandensis, Trinity Church Choir, New York | E Major | 12B | 71 |
| 15 | ![Infant Holy, Infant Lowly (Arr. D. Willcocks for choir) by Traditional, Trinity Church Choir, New York]() | Infant Holy, Infant Lowly (Arr. D. Willcocks for choir) | Traditional, Trinity Church Choir, New York | A♭ Major | 4B | 91 |
| 16 | ![Gabriel's Message (Arr. E. Pettman for choir) by Traditional, Trinity Church Choir, New York]() | Gabriel's Message (Arr. E. Pettman for choir) | Traditional, Trinity Church Choir, New York | A Minor | 8A | 127 |
| 17 | ![Lullay my Liking, Op. 34, No. 2: Lullay, My Liking by Gustav Holst, Trinity Church Choir, New York]() | Lullay my Liking, Op. 34, No. 2: Lullay, My Liking | Gustav Holst, Trinity Church Choir, New York | A Minor | 8A | 110 |
| 18 | ![Resonet In Laudibus (Arr. J. Handl for choir) by Traditional, Trinity Church Choir, New York]() | Resonet In Laudibus (Arr. J. Handl for choir) | Traditional, Trinity Church Choir, New York | F Major | 7B | 130 |
| 19 | ![Angels from the Realms of Glory by Traditional, Trinity Church Choir, New York, Owen Burdick]() | Angels from the Realms of Glory | Traditional, Trinity Church Choir, New York, Owen Burdick | G Major | 9B | 57 |
| 20 | ![Sussex Carol]() | Sussex Carol "On Christmas Night" | Traditional, Trinity Church Choir, New York, Owen Burdick | G Major | 9B | 84 |
| 21 | ![A Babe Is Born by William Mathias, Trinity Church Choir, New York, Owen Burdick]() | A Babe Is Born | William Mathias, Trinity Church Choir, New York, Owen Burdick | C Major | 8B | 129 |
| 22 | ![Silent Night (Arr. P. Ledger for choir) by Franz Xaver Gruber, Philip Ledger, Trinity Church Choir, New York, Owen Burdick]() | Silent Night (Arr. P. Ledger for choir) | Franz Xaver Gruber, Philip Ledger, Trinity Church Choir, New York, Owen Burdick | C Major | 8B | 74 |
| 23 | ![Hark! The Herald Angels Sing: Festgesang, MWV D4,]() | Hark! The Herald Angels Sing: Festgesang, MWV D4, "Gutenberg-Kantate": No. 2, (adap. W.H. Cummings as Hark! The Herald Angels Sing) [arr. D. Willcocks for choir] [Arr. D. Willcocks] | Felix Mendelssohn, Trinity Church Choir, New York | G Major | 9B | 84 |