| 1 | ![Rutter: Shepherd's Pipe Carol by John Rutter, Clare College Singers, Jeremy Blandford, Clare College Orchestra]() | Rutter: Shepherd's Pipe Carol | John Rutter, Clare College Singers, Jeremy Blandford, Clare College Orchestra | F Major | 7B | 133 |
| 2 | ![Traditional: Infant Holy, Infant Lowly by Traditional, Clare College Singers, Jeremy Blandford, Simon Vaughan, John Rutter, Clare College Orchestra]() | Traditional: Infant Holy, Infant Lowly | Traditional, Clare College Singers, Jeremy Blandford, Simon Vaughan, John Rutter, Clare College Orchestra | A♭ Major | 4B | 90 |
| 3 | ![Traditional / Arr Rutter: Angel Tidings by Traditional, Clare College Singers, John Rutter, Clare College Orchestra]() | Traditional / Arr Rutter: Angel Tidings | Traditional, Clare College Singers, John Rutter, Clare College Orchestra | A♭ Major | 4B | 122 |
| 4 | ![Traditional: Quelle est cette odeur agréable? - French Christmas Carol from the 17th Century by Anonymous, Clare College Singers, Clare College Orchestra, Jeremy Blandford, John Rutter]() | Traditional: Quelle est cette odeur agréable? - French Christmas Carol from the 17th Century | Anonymous, Clare College Singers, Clare College Orchestra, Jeremy Blandford, John Rutter | E Major | 12B | 84 |
| 5 | ![Gauntlett / Arr. Rutter: Irby]() | Gauntlett / Arr. Rutter: Irby "Once in Royal David's City" | Henry John Gauntlett, Clare College Singers, Jeremy Blandford, John Rutter, Clare College Orchestra | G Major | 9B | 81 |
| 6 | ![Traditional: Il est né, le divin Enfant (French Carol) by Traditional, Clare College Singers, Clare College Orchestra, Jeremy Blandford, John Rutter]() | Traditional: Il est né, le divin Enfant (French Carol) | Traditional, Clare College Singers, Clare College Orchestra, Jeremy Blandford, John Rutter | A♭ Major | 4B | 74 |
| 7 | ![Rutter / Traditional: I Saw Three Ships:]() | Rutter / Traditional: I Saw Three Ships: "I saw three ships come sailing in" (English Christmas Carol) | Traditional, Clare College Singers | A Major | 11B | 85 |
| 8 | ![Traditional / Arr. Rutter: In dulci jubilo by Traditional, Clare College Singers, John Rutter, Clare College Orchestra]() | Traditional / Arr. Rutter: In dulci jubilo | Traditional, Clare College Singers, John Rutter, Clare College Orchestra | G Major | 9B | 95 |
| 9 | ![Rutter: Nativity Carol by John Rutter, Clare College Singers, Jeremy Blandford, Clare College Orchestra]() | Rutter: Nativity Carol | John Rutter, Clare College Singers, Jeremy Blandford, Clare College Orchestra | D Major | 10B | 78 |
| 10 | ![Anonymous: Quem pastores laudavere (from]() | Anonymous: Quem pastores laudavere (from "Hohenfurth Manuscript, 1410") | Traditional, Clare College Singers, Clare College Orchestra, Jeremy Blandford, John Rutter | F♯ Major | 2B | 65 |
| 11 | ![Shaw / Traditional: Hajej, nynjej,]() | Shaw / Traditional: Hajej, nynjej, "Rocking Carol": "Hajej, nynej, Jezisku, Jezisku" (Czech Carol) | Traditional, Roger Garland, Clare College Singers, Clare College Orchestra, Jeremy Blandford, John Rutter | F Major | 7B | 54 |
| 12 | ![The Twelve Days of Christmas by Frederic Austin, Clare College Singers, Clare College Orchestra, Jeremy Blandford, John Rutter]() | The Twelve Days of Christmas | Frederic Austin, Clare College Singers, Clare College Orchestra, Jeremy Blandford, John Rutter | A♭ Major | 4B | 80 |
| 13 | ![Traditional: Here We Come A-wassailing,]() | Traditional: Here We Come A-wassailing, "Wassail Song" (English Christmas Carol) | Traditional, Clare College Singers, Jeremy Blandford, John Rutter, Clare College Orchestra | E Major | 12B | 88 |
| 14 | ![Rutter: The Coming of our King (After a Polish Carol) by Traditional, Clare College Singers, Clare College Orchestra, Jeremy Blandford, John Rutter]() | Rutter: The Coming of our King (After a Polish Carol) | Traditional, Clare College Singers, Clare College Orchestra, Jeremy Blandford, John Rutter | F Major | 7B | 122 |
| 15 | ![Neale / Traditional: O Come, O Come, Emmanuel (Christian Hymn for Advent) by 13th century, Clare College Singers, Simon Vaughan, Jeremy Blandford, John Rutter, Clare College Orchestra]() | Neale / Traditional: O Come, O Come, Emmanuel (Christian Hymn for Advent) | 13th century, Clare College Singers, Simon Vaughan, Jeremy Blandford, John Rutter, Clare College Orchestra | E Minor | 9A | 56 |
| 16 | ![Baring-Gould / Traditional: The Infant King (Old Basque Noël) by Traditional, Clare College Singers, Jeremy Blandford, John Rutter, Clare College Orchestra]() | Baring-Gould / Traditional: The Infant King (Old Basque Noël) | Traditional, Clare College Singers, Jeremy Blandford, John Rutter, Clare College Orchestra | F Major | 7B | 131 |
| 17 | ![Rutter / Traditional: Shepherds' Noël (Catalan Carol) by Traditional, Simon Vaughan, Clare College Singers, Clare College Orchestra, Jeremy Blandford, John Rutter]() | Rutter / Traditional: Shepherds' Noël (Catalan Carol) | Traditional, Simon Vaughan, Clare College Singers, Clare College Orchestra, Jeremy Blandford, John Rutter | D Major | 10B | 176 |
| 18 | ![Noël nouvelet by Traditional, Clare College Singers, Clare College Orchestra, Jeremy Blandford, John Rutter]() | Noël nouvelet | Traditional, Clare College Singers, Clare College Orchestra, Jeremy Blandford, John Rutter | D Minor | 7A | 130 |
| 19 | ![Traditional / Arr. Rutter: O Little Town of Bethlehem by Traditional, Clare College Singers, Simon Vaughan, John Rutter, Clare College Orchestra]() | Traditional / Arr. Rutter: O Little Town of Bethlehem | Traditional, Clare College Singers, Simon Vaughan, John Rutter, Clare College Orchestra | F Major | 7B | 78 |
| 20 | ![Baring-Gould / Traditional: Gabriel's Message (Basque Carol) by Traditional, Simon Vaughan, Clare College Singers, Clare College Orchestra, Jeremy Blandford, John Rutter]() | Baring-Gould / Traditional: Gabriel's Message (Basque Carol) | Traditional, Simon Vaughan, Clare College Singers, Clare College Orchestra, Jeremy Blandford, John Rutter | A Minor | 8A | 96 |
| 21 | ![Traditional: Sans Day Carol,]() | Traditional: Sans Day Carol, "St. Day Carol": "Now the holly bears a berry" (Cornish Christmas Carol) | Traditional, Clare College Singers, John Rutter, Clare College Orchestra | E♭ Major | 5B | 130 |
| 22 | ![Gruber / Arr. Rutter: Stille Nacht, heilige Nacht by Franz Xaver Gruber, Clare College Singers, Clare College Orchestra, Jeremy Blandford, John Rutter]() | Gruber / Arr. Rutter: Stille Nacht, heilige Nacht | Franz Xaver Gruber, Clare College Singers, Clare College Orchestra, Jeremy Blandford, John Rutter | C Major | 8B | 59 |
| 23 | ![Traditional: A Little Child:]() | Traditional: A Little Child: "A Little child on the earth has been born" (After a Flemish Carol) | Traditional Flemish, Clare College Singers, Clare College Orchestra, Jeremy Blandford, John Rutter | C Major | 8B | 79 |
| 24 | ![Traditional: Past Three O'Clock,]() | Traditional: Past Three O'Clock, "Past Three A Clock" (English Carol) | Traditional, Clare College Singers, Clare College Orchestra, Jeremy Blandford, John Rutter | A Major | 11B | 82 |